Weekly Briefing No.
1
·
Week of September 20 – 26, 2026

The courts had a busy week

Almost every major development this week went through a courtroom. The Supreme Court settled which congressional map Missouri will use in November and let a federal citizenship-check tool for voter rolls resume. Lower courts rejected another Justice Department demand for a state's voter file, restored White House press access for three outlets, and held the Department of Homeland Security in contempt. Outside the courts, a late-September rescission request could let about $800 million in appropriated funds expire before Congress votes.

Published
September 26, 2026
Edited by Dabney Standley
Electoral Integrity
mixed
Courts upheld state control of maps and voter files, but a federal citizenship-check tool returned while its privacy case is unresolved.
Civil Liberties
mixed
A judge restored press access that had been revoked without notice. A privacy injunction on voter-data matching was lifted before a final ruling.
Rule of Law
down
A federal judge found DHS in contempt for the second time in the same case. Courts are enforcing their orders, but agencies are still violating them.
Checks & Balances
mixed
A pocket rescission tests Congress's control of spending. A settlement restored civil-service protections during shutdowns.
Political Pluralism
hold
A state probe of the main Democratic fundraising platform is lawful process for now. We are watching how it is used.
Transparency & Anti-Corruption
hold
A quiet week. One court ordered ICE to release records it had withheld.
Democratic Culture
hold
Threats against officials continued, and prosecutors charged them. New survey data shows low public confidence that leaders will be held accountable.

The week in brief

Almost every major development this week went through a courtroom. On the same Friday, the Supreme Court settled which congressional map Missouri will use in November and let a federal citizenship-check tool for voter rolls resume. Lower courts rejected another Justice Department demand for a state's full voter file, ordered White House press access restored for three outlets, and held the Department of Homeland Security in contempt. The one major test outside the courts was a late-September rescission request. Because it arrives just as the fiscal year ends, it could let about $800 million in appropriated funds expire before Congress votes.

The week's events

  • Sept 21 · Michigan charges two people over threats to officials and justices · Democratic Culture
  • Sept 22 · Judge dismisses DOJ suit for Washington's full voter file · Electoral Integrity · Checks & Balances
  • Sept 24 · Judge orders White House to restore access for CNN, MS NOW, and Politico · Civil Liberties
  • Sept 25 · Supreme Court requires Missouri's 2022 map for November · Electoral Integrity · Checks & Balances
  • Sept 25 · Supreme Court lets expanded SAVE citizenship checks resume, 6–3 · Electoral Integrity · Civil Liberties
  • Sept 25 · DHS held in contempt a second time over a twice-deported asylum seeker · Rule of Law
  • Sept 25 · Settlement rescinds the shutdown layoff policy and voids about 4,200 notices · Checks & Balances
  • Sept 25 · Missouri attorney general opens investigation into ActBlue · Political Pluralism
  • Sept 25 · White House proposes a pocket rescission of about $810 million · Checks & Balances

The full edition

The complete edition, as sent to subscribers. Get it in your inbox every Friday. How the signals work: Methodology.

Welcome to the first weekly issue. Each Friday, the Democracy Monitor reviews the week's institutional news and gives each of seven pillars one of four signals: Strengthening, Holding, Mixed, or Eroding. We judge the mechanism, not the party. A court blocking an executive action reads the same no matter who is president. Every event carries a counter-read, which is the strongest case that we have it wrong. The full method, the seven pillars, and their history are on the Democracy Monitor site.

Electoral Integrity

Supreme Court requires Missouri's 2022 map for November

Instrument: unsigned Supreme Court order, People Not Politicians v. Onder · Status: final for the 2026 election; the referendum on the new map is pending · Date: Sept. 25

Missouri's legislature redrew its congressional map in 2025. Citizens then qualified a referendum petition against it, and on Sept. 3 the Missouri Supreme Court ruled that the 2022 map stays in force until voters decide. On Sept. 21, a panel of the 8th Circuit ordered the state to use the 2025 map anyway. The panel reasoned that changing district lines between the August primary and the general election raised equal-protection problems. Four days later the Supreme Court overruled the panel with no noted dissents. It said the 8th Circuit's reliance on the Purcell principle (the doctrine that federal courts should avoid changing election rules close to an election) was incorrect. The 2025 map will appear on the November ballot as Proposition A.

Our reading: Electoral Integrity holding. A state's referendum process and its highest court's reading of state law were given effect. Checks & Balances strengthening, because the Supreme Court held a lower court to its earlier orders.

Counter-read: Candidates and voters who went through the primary in 2025 districts now face different lines in the general election. That confusion is a real cost to the fairness of the election.

Sources: Missouri Independent, Sept. 25 · Missouri Independent, Sept. 21 · Law Dork

Supreme Court lets expanded SAVE citizenship checks resume, 6–3

Instrument: Supreme Court order lifting an injunction, DHS v. League of Women Voters · Status: preliminary; the case continues on the merits · Date: Sept. 25

The 2025 overhaul of SAVE, a Homeland Security database, lets election officials check voter rolls against federal citizenship records in bulk, searching by Social Security number. U.S. District Judge Sparkle Sooknanan (D.D.C.) had blocked the expanded system on privacy grounds. The Supreme Court lifted her injunction, 6–3. Justices Sotomayor, Kagan, and Jackson dissented. Jackson wrote that burdening even a few lawful voters outweighs a harm she called "nonexistent." Federal law bars states from systematically removing voters within 90 days of a federal election, which limits what the tool can do before Nov. 3.

Our reading: Electoral Integrity mixed. A new federal verification tool enters voter-roll maintenance while the courts have not yet decided whether it is accurate or lawful. Civil Liberties eroding, because a privacy protection was removed before a final ruling.

Counter-read: Checking citizenship against federal records is a lawful eligibility safeguard that states themselves requested. The 90-day rule sharply limits removals before this election.

Sources: CBS News · Votebeat

Judge dismisses DOJ suit for Washington's full voter file

Instrument: district court dismissal, W.D. Wash. · Status: final at the district level; an appeal is possible · Date: Sept. 22

The Justice Department sued Washington for its complete voter file, including dates of birth, driver's license numbers, and partial Social Security numbers. Secretary of State Steve Hobbs had offered the less sensitive fields. U.S. District Judge Kymberly Evanson dismissed the case. She found that DOJ's reading of the National Voter Registration Act, the Help America Vote Act, and the Civil Rights Act of 1960 does not hold up as statutory interpretation. Washington Attorney General Nick Brown says DOJ has now lost all 25 of these suits nationwide. Appeals in Massachusetts, Wisconsin, and Minnesota are fully briefed.

Our reading: Electoral Integrity and Checks & Balances holding. Courts continue to leave control of voter data with the states.

Counter-read: Federal law does give DOJ a role in enforcing election statutes, and an appeals court could read that role more broadly than district courts have.

Sources: Washington State Standard · UW State Democracy Research Initiative tracker

Civil Liberties

Judge orders White House to restore access for CNN, MS NOW, and Politico

Instrument: 14-day temporary restraining order, D.D.C. · Status: preliminary; preliminary-injunction briefing is due by Oct. 5, and the administration has said it will appeal · Date: Sept. 24

On Sept. 18 the president barred the three outlets over their coverage, and the next day the Secret Service took their credentials. U.S. District Judge Timothy Kelly, who was appointed in Trump's first term, found the outlets likely to win on due-process grounds because they received no notice and no chance to respond. He also doubted the administration's later national-security rationale, noting that nothing in the record from before the lawsuit supported it. The reporters were back on the grounds the same day, Sept. 24.

Our reading: Civil Liberties strengthening. A court checked a press exclusion based on the outlets' coverage. Rule of Law holding, because the administration complied promptly.

Counter-read: Access to the White House grounds is discretionary. In a separate case involving the Associated Press, the D.C. Circuit largely let the administration's restrictions stand, so this win may not last.

From the archive: In Sherrill v. Knight (1977), the D.C. Circuit held that the Secret Service could not deny a reporter a White House press pass without notice, a stated reason, and a chance to respond. The case arose when the service denied a pass to Robert Sherrill of The Nation. Judge Kelly's order rests on the same principle, nearly fifty years later: the government may set conditions on access, but it must follow a fair process when it takes access away.

Sources: CBS News · PBS NewsHour

Rule of Law

DHS held in contempt a second time over a twice-deported asylum seeker

Instrument: civil contempt finding, D. Md., J.O.P. v. DHS · Status: final at the district level; the return order has not yet been carried out · Date: Sept. 25

U.S. District Judge Stephanie Gallagher, a Trump appointee, found that the government had violated three court orders (issued in November 2024, April 2025, and July 2026) by removing a 19-year-old asylum seeker to El Salvador. She ordered him returned along with his property and documents. She also barred his removal until his asylum claim is decided. This is her second contempt finding in the same class action, which began in 2019 over asylum claims filed by young people.

Our reading: Rule of Law eroding. A court order means something only if agencies follow it, and here one agency violated three orders in a single case. Separately, on Sept. 24, a federal judge in a FOIA case (Transgender Law Center v. ICE, D.D.C.) sharply criticized ICE for not following earlier court orders to release records.

Counter-read: In a system handling a very high volume of removals, violations may reflect administrative failure rather than deliberate defiance, and the government can appeal the finding.

Sources: Bloomberg Law · Axios · FOIA Advisor summary of Sept. 24 opinions

Checks & Balances

White House sends a roughly $800 million pocket rescission

Instrument: rescission proposal under the Impoundment Control Act · Status: pending; the fiscal year ends Sept. 30 · Date: Sept. 26

Under the Impoundment Control Act, a president may propose canceling appropriated funds, and Congress has 45 days to approve. A "pocket rescission" is a proposal sent so late that the money expires before those 45 days run out. That lets the funds lapse without a vote. This proposal targets more than $800 million, including $567 million at the Department of Health and Human Services, with the rest at Homeland Security, Education, Housing and Urban Development, and Justice. The Government Accountability Office has concluded that pocket rescissions are unlawful. Sen. Susan Collins (R-Maine), who chairs the Senate Appropriations Committee, called the move "a clear violation of the law." In 2025 the Supreme Court allowed a $4 billion foreign-aid pocket rescission to proceed, while stating that it had not decided the underlying legal question.

Our reading: Checks & Balances eroding. Using timing to let appropriated money expire moves spending power from Congress to the executive.

Counter-read: The Act's text arguably permits a late proposal. The 2025 rescission was not blocked. The president is formally asking Congress rather than refusing to spend in silence.

From the archive: After President Nixon refused to spend billions that Congress had appropriated, Congress passed the Impoundment Control Act in 1974. In Train v. City of New York (1975), the Supreme Court ruled that Nixon's EPA could not withhold Clean Water Act funds that Congress had directed it to allot. Fifty years later, this week's dispute is over whether a proposal timed to run out the clock gets around the law that Congress wrote to prevent impoundment.

Sources: ABC News

Settlement rescinds the shutdown layoff policy and voids about 4,200 notices

Instrument: court-supervised settlement, N.D. Cal. · Status: final (settlement); the case is paused through year-end and can be reopened · Date: Sept. 25

The Office of Personnel Management and the Office of Management and Budget settled a suit led by the American Federation of Government Employees. The policy that allowed layoffs during a shutdown is rescinded. About 4,200 layoff notices issued during the 43-day shutdown are voided, and those employees will be reinstated. Agencies must remove layoff authority from their shutdown plans and post those plans publicly.

Our reading: Checks & Balances strengthening. Civil-service protections were restored through a process the court oversees.

Counter-read: This is a settlement, not a ruling. It leaves the legal question open and expires at the end of the year.

Sources: Government Executive

Political Pluralism

Missouri attorney general opens investigation into ActBlue

Instrument: civil investigative demand under the Missouri Merchandising Practices Act · Status: pending; documents are due Oct. 8 · Date: announced this week (reported Sept. 25)

Attorney General Catherine Hanaway is investigating ActBlue, the main online fundraising platform for Democratic candidates. She alleges weak donor verification and misrepresentation of foreign contributions. The probe follows a Texas lawsuit and several years of House committee investigations. ActBlue denies wrongdoing.

Our reading: Political Pluralism holding, with a flag. Consumer-protection investigations are lawful. Aiming one at the opposing party's core fundraising system six weeks before an election is the kind of step we will keep watching.

Counter-read: Preventing fraud and foreign money in campaigns is a legitimate enforcement goal, and congressional reports have cited internal warnings at ActBlue.

Sources: Missouri Attorney General's Office · KCTV5

Democratic Culture

Michigan charges two people over threats to officials and justices

Instrument: state criminal charges · Status: pending · Date: Sept. 21

Attorney General Dana Nessel charged a Lake Orion man with nine counts of making terrorism threats. He allegedly emailed threats against the Michigan Supreme Court, Gov. Gretchen Whitmer, and Secretary of State Jocelyn Benson to a journalist. A Roseville woman was charged separately over threats against a mosque and Dearborn Mayor Abdullah Hammoud.

Our reading: Democratic Culture holding. Threats against officials continue, but prosecutors are treating them as crimes.

Counter-read: Charging threatening speech as terrorism carries sentences of up to 20 years, and some will see that as prosecutorial overreach.

Sources: Michigan Attorney General

Data point of the week. A Kettering Foundation and Gallup survey of 23,683 adults, conducted April 24 to June 10 and released Sept. 23, found that 56% of Americans think the rule of law is weaker than it was a decade ago, and 14% think it is stronger. While 78% say officials must always follow the law, only 28% trust that political leaders will be held accountable to it, down from 32% in 2025. (Kettering Foundation · Axios)

Watch next week

  • Sept. 30: The fiscal year ends. Will the rescinded funds lapse, and will Congress, GAO, or a lawsuit respond?
  • Oct. 5: Briefing is due on a preliminary injunction in the White House press case. The restraining order expires around Oct. 8.
  • Oct. 5: The Supreme Court's new term opens.
  • Oct. 8: ActBlue's deadline to respond to Missouri's demand.

What we could not verify

We found no significant, verifiable transparency or ethics event this week beyond the FOIA ruling above. We have not confirmed the name of the judge who approved the union settlement. We relied on reporting rather than the underlying court orders for the Missouri map and contempt rulings. Corrections run at the top of the next issue.

Our full source list and standards are on the sources page.

Past briefings