Weekly Briefing No.
·
Special Election Edition · the Nov. 3, 2026 midterms

The states counted the votes. The fight over who controls the count is not over.

The Nov. 3 midterm was run by the states and counted by local officials with routine problems and no breakdown, under heavy federal pressure. Courts stopped every demand to set aside ballots that reached them, and the president said he would accept the results. Several tools used this fall remain available, and Alaska's count is still open.

Published
November 7, 2026
Edited by Dabney Standley
Electoral Integrity
Civil Liberties
Rule of Law
Checks & Balances
Political Pluralism
Transparency & Anti-Corruption
Democratic Culture

The week in brief

The Constitution leaves the “Times, Places and Manner” of congressional elections to the states, subject to laws Congress passes. On Nov. 3 the states ran the election, local officials counted it and, by every account we found, it was conducted with routine problems and no breakdown. That happened under federal pressure of a kind one election law scholar said he had never seen before a vote.

Through October the Justice Department and Homeland Security pressed states to set aside ballots of voters on federal lists of suspected noncitizens, sued to hold up certification of a Senate race, and warned election officials in every state of prosecution. Courts stopped every demand to sideline ballots that reached them, including at the Supreme Court, with no noted dissent.

Voters in Missouri used a referendum to overturn a mid-decade map.

The president said he would accept the results, and the losing candidates we could check conceded. The easy case held: margins were wide. Several tools used this fall remain available, one court protection for election workers was stayed on Election Day, and Alaska's count is still open.

The week's events

  • 11 efforts tracked to change who voted, which ballots counted, or certification
  • Stopped: 6
  • Partly succeeded: 1
  • Succeeded: 0
  • Still open: 4

The full edition

The complete edition, as sent to subscribers. Get it in your inbox every Friday. How the signals work: Methodology.

About this edition. This is a one-time edition, published alongside regular issue No. 7. It is not a weekly reading and does not change the weekly signals. It judges the mechanisms of the election, how votes were cast and counted and how institutions responded to pressure on that process, and not who won.

Part 1. What happened

Voting and counting. Problems on Election Day were the ordinary kind. In Westchester County, N.Y., scanners rejected ballots after a programming update made after the equipment was tested; voters kept voting, ballots went into emergency bags, and a judge let the county move them under police escort to a secure warehouse for scanning. County Executive Ken Jenkins called it a "debacle" and promised a bipartisan investigation. A malfunction delayed voting about 20 minutes in Broward County, Fla. Hours were extended at three sites in Pennsylvania and five in North Carolina. Rain and flash flooding in Colorado, Arizona, Utah and New Mexico, and flooding in eight Florida counties, moved polling places, including several on the Navajo Nation. In Milwaukee, two workers failed to write identifying numbers on 242 absentee ballots, which were still counted. David Becker of the Center for Election Innovation & Research called the small number of problems "remarkable." Votebeat's summary was that problems were "fairly typical for a big election."

Sources: AP via OPB, Nov. 3 · AP via WCTV, Nov. 3 · Votebeat, Nov. 4 · Votebeat, Nov. 5 · Votebeat live blog, Nov. 3

Federal presence at the polls. The Justice Department announced on Election Day what it called the largest monitoring effort in its history, about 1,000 monitors and observers in all 50 states. The day before, U.S. District Judge Reggie Walton denied the NAACP's request to bar law enforcement officers from serving as monitors, relying on the government's commitments that monitors would be unarmed and without arrest power. Votebeat found reports of observers overstepping in Michigan and New Mexico and no disruption of polling places. No federal agents or troops were reported at the polls. U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement posted a warning on X to anyone voting illegally: "We will track you down, arrest you, and prosecute you."

Sources: Los Angeles Times via News Tribune, Nov. 4 · Just Security litigation tracker, updated Nov. 5 · Votebeat, Nov. 4 · AP via OPB, Nov. 3

Threats and violence. We found no report in the sources we opened of violence against voters or election workers at the polls on Nov. 3. The pressure on election workers this fall came mostly through official channels. In sworn declarations, the Santa Clara County registrar described a "severe chilling effect" on his staff, and the Contra Costa County clerk said two Homeland Security officials arrived unannounced on Oct. 23 and gave her 48 hours to set aside as many as 407 ballots. Officials and experts told The New York Times, as summarized by Just Security, that covert foreign interference was minimal.

Sources: Votebeat, Nov. 2 · Just Security, Early Edition, Nov. 6

Turnout. We do not yet have a reliable national turnout figure. AP reported that early voting surpassed the 2022 midterm. Georgia counted 1,005,130 ballots by the evening of Oct. 19, six days into early voting. One Pennsylvania county director called the day "very boring, but with very good turnout."

Sources: AP via WCTV, Nov. 3 · Atlanta News First, Oct. 19 · Votebeat, Nov. 4

Ballot measures that change democratic institutions. Missouri voters rejected Proposition A, the 2025 congressional map that split Kansas City into three districts, 62% to 38%, according to AP. They also approved Amendment 6, which bars the legislature from passing laws that override referendum results. Arizona voters were rejecting Proposition 144, a legislative referral that would have required ID from all voters including mail voters and told state courts to apply a lower standard when reviewing election laws, 53% to 47% with 89% of the expected vote counted on Thursday evening. In Alaska, with 98% of precincts reporting on election night, voters were narrowly keeping ranked-choice voting, with "No" on repeal near 52%; a 2024 repeal effort lost by 743 votes once late ballots came in, so this could still move. A separate Alaska measure stating that "only" citizens may vote was passing.

Sources: St. Louis Public Radio, Nov. 3 · Votebeat, Nov. 6 · Alaska Public Media, Nov. 3

Election administrators on the ballot. In Arizona, Secretary of State Adrian Fontes, a Democrat, won a second term over Republican Alex Kolodin, who had filed a 2020 lawsuit that Votebeat describes as baselessly alleging the election was stolen. Fontes had nearly 55% with 83% counted. Kolodin acknowledged the result on social media. In Michigan, Lt. Gov. Garlin Gilchrist, a Democrat, defeated Macomb County Clerk Anthony Forlini, a Republican, 53% to 44% at the time AP called the race; Gilchrist has said he will keep the state's voter roll from the Justice Department. We could not verify results for other secretary of state races or a national count of candidates whom advocacy groups label election deniers.

Sources: Votebeat, Nov. 4 · Votebeat, Nov. 4

Acceptance and concessions. On election night the president told The New York Times he was "absolutely willing to accept those results," and in later interviews and a post he acknowledged his party's losses. A week earlier he had said he would accept them "if they are honest." Rep. Mike Lawler conceded in Westchester before AP called his race. Tom Tiffany, the Republican candidate for governor of Wisconsin, conceded on election night. Votebeat reported that Sen. Dan Sullivan of Alaska signaled acceptance or cooperation. By the end of election night, Votebeat found no major statewide or national Republican figure disputing results. In Mississippi, The Hill reported, as summarized by Just Security, that the state Republican chairman said the party would accept a Democratic Senate win if the laws are followed. Cleta Mitchell, a conservative election activist, urged supporters to look to future fights rather than contest Tuesday's results, writing that "When election results are not close …. no one looks under the hood." We found no major candidate who refused to concede.

Sources: AP via WCTV, Nov. 3 · AFP via RTÉ, Nov. 4 · AP via OPB, Nov. 3 · Votebeat, Nov. 5 · Votebeat, Nov. 4 · Just Security, Early Edition, Nov. 6

Results, as context only. AP projected that Democrats won control of both the House and the Senate, with many races still uncalled on Nov. 4. Alaska's Senate race is undecided: Mary Peltola, a Democrat, held a narrow lead over Sen. Dan Sullivan without a majority, so a ranked-choice tabulation is expected to begin Nov. 18. Counting continues in several states, and certification lies ahead.

Sources: AAP via St George & Sutherland Shire Leader, Nov. 4 · Votebeat, Nov. 4

Part 2. The pressure on the process

These are the significant efforts we found, from late summer through Nov. 7, to change who could vote, which ballots counted, who counted them, or whether results would be certified. We include lawful enforcement alongside contested tactics, and allegations against either side where they led to official action.

1. The Justice Department's voter-roll policy

Who and how: The Justice Department, through what a federal judge called its Voter List Maintenance Policy, urged states to remove voters it deemed ineligible, using federal citizenship data.

What happened: On Oct. 9, U.S. District Judge Sparkle Sooknanan vacated the policy in Common Cause v. Department of Justice. The department appealed to the D.C. Circuit on Oct. 16.

Outcome: Stopped.

What stopped it (or didn't): Judicial review under federal administrative law. The appeal is pending, and the department read the ruling narrowly enough to bring the California case below a week later.

Sources: Just Security litigation tracker

2. Homeland Security investigations of suspected noncitizen voters

Who and how: Homeland Security agents ran field investigations of people on federal lists of suspected noncitizen voters in nine states, with a "surge" phase from late August in which reviews were limited to 12 minutes per person.

What happened: On Oct. 21, U.S. District Judge Araceli Martinez-Olguin called the lists "voluminous and unreliable" and ordered the investigations halted in California, Connecticut, Georgia, Missouri, Nevada, New York, Pennsylvania, Washington and Wisconsin until polls closed. On Oct. 30, a Ninth Circuit panel refused to lift her order, finding that the investigations had deterred some citizens from election activity, and the full court declined review.

Outcome: Partly succeeded.

What stopped it (or didn't): A district court and the Ninth Circuit, but only for the final two weeks before polls closed, and on the ground that the investigations harmed groups that help people vote, not on a finding that anyone's right to vote was violated. The investigations ran for weeks before the order, and nothing bars them from resuming now.

Sources: AP via ClickOrlando, Oct. 22 · AP via KSAT, Oct. 30 · Just Security litigation tracker

3. Setting aside about 20,000 California mail ballots

Who and how: On Oct. 13, Acting Deputy Attorney General Trent McCotter gave California officials 48 hours to check a federal list of about 20,000 voters and segregate the mail ballots of anyone not verified. When they refused, the department sued on Oct. 15 in United States v. California.

What happened: Los Angeles County found that only 7,035 of the names had county addresses, and in a sample of 200, 38.9% of those with a meaningfully reported birthplace were born in the United States. Judge David Carter denied a temporary order on Oct. 28, writing that "California and its people are sovereign, too." A Ninth Circuit panel denied relief 2–1 on Oct. 30, finding "no feasible way" to pull specific ballots out. On Nov. 2 the Supreme Court denied the department's emergency application in a brief unsigned order with no noted dissent. The same day, Chief Judge James Boasberg barred the administration from demanding that California officials segregate those ballots, finding the executive branch "has likely violated the Constitution's Elections Clause."

Outcome: Stopped.

What stopped it (or didn't): County and state officials who refused the demand, then courts at three levels. On Nov. 6, about a week before a scheduled hearing, the department moved to dismiss its own suit, saying the relief it sought "is no longer available." (AP via PBS, Nov. 7)

Sources: AP via WDIV, Oct. 14 · NPR via WYPR, Oct. 20 · Votebeat, Oct. 29 · AP via KSAT, Oct. 30 · SCOTUSblog, Nov. 2 · AP via The Week, Nov. 3 · Reuters via KFGO, Nov. 2

4. Direct demands to California county registrars

Who and how: On Oct. 23, federal prosecutors sent letters to county registrars asking them to sequester ballots of listed voters within 48 hours and turn over sensitive data, warning that officials who knowingly count a noncitizen's vote could face legal action. In Napa County, two uniformed Homeland Security officers delivered the letter.

What happened: The department had asked a court for the same relief and not received it. The California attorney general's office said the letters contained errors; Mendocino County got names of people who do not live there. "We're proceeding with the election," said Napa's registrar, John Tuteur.

Outcome: Stopped.

What stopped it (or didn't): Local officials who declined to act without a court order. Nothing stopped the letters from arriving, and they put personal legal risk on county staff in the middle of voting.

Sources: AP via News4Jax, Oct. 24 · Votebeat, Nov. 2

5. Setting aside ballots in Washington state

Who and how: On Oct. 26, the Justice Department told Washington officials to separate as many as 400 ballots from people it called possible noncitizens.

What happened: Secretary of State Steve Hobbs refused after an initial check found citizens on the list, saying that refusing a registered voter's ballot without individualized proof of ineligibility would be illegal. On Nov. 5, Politico reported, as summarized by Just Security, that a federal judge issued a two-week order barring the department from demanding that Washington officials set aside ballots or threatening them with prosecution for counting votes.

Outcome: Stopped.

What stopped it (or didn't): The state's chief election officer, then a federal court during the canvass.

Sources: Votebeat, Oct. 29 · Just Security, Early Edition, Nov. 6

6. Sending federal lists of suspected noncitizens to states

Who and how: The Justice Department and Homeland Security sent states lists of registered voters they suspected were not citizens and asked officials to act on them.

What happened: On Nov. 2, in a suit by the League of Women Voters and others, U.S. District Judge Tanya Chutkan temporarily barred the two departments from sending such lists to state or local officials or asking them to set aside those voters' ballots. Individual citizenship checks through the SAVE system remain allowed. The department had argued its letters were law enforcement, not "a distinct policy subject to review by a federal court."

Outcome: Stopped.

What stopped it (or didn't): A federal court applying privacy and administrative law. The order is preliminary.

Sources: Reuters via WTVB, Nov. 2 · Just Security litigation tracker

7. Prosecution warnings to election officials

Who and how: On Oct. 29, McCotter signed identical letters, which officials said appeared to go to all 50 states, reminding election officials that failing to keep records for 22 months is "punishable by up to a year in prison and a $1,000 fine." The letters named no violation. The same week, federal prosecutors served grand jury subpoenas on Los Angeles County election officials, and at least three were asked to appear the day after the election.

What happened: Joshua Douglas, a University of Kentucky law professor, said he had "never seen the DOJ send this kind of letter across the country" before an election. On Oct. 30, U.S. District Judge Trina Thompson barred the Justice Department and Homeland Security from threatening election workers with prosecution over the ballot demands. Late on Nov. 2, a divided Ninth Circuit panel stayed her order and held that Section 11(b) of the Voting Rights Act gives private groups no right to sue; the full court vacated that stay within hours. According to the Just Security litigation tracker, on Nov. 3 the full court then voted to reinstate the panel's decision for the government and denied rehearing, and on Nov. 4 Judge Thompson paused further proceedings while the appeal continues. We could not open those orders.

Outcome: Still open.

What stopped it (or didn't): No official was charged, and no court has found that any official violated the records law. But the warnings reached every state, the subpoenas went out, and the main court protection against such threats appears to have been stayed on Election Day. We do not know whether the Los Angeles officials appeared before the grand jury.

Sources: Votebeat, Oct. 30 · AP via KSAT, Oct. 30 · Raw Story, Nov. 3 · Just Security litigation tracker

8. A federal suit to hold up Alaska's Senate certification

Who and how: The Justice Department sued in late October to block certification of Alaska's Senate result if Sen. Dan Sullivan lost narrowly, arguing that a second candidate, Daniel J. Sullivan, confused voters. The president said he personally ordered the suit.

What happened: On Nov. 1, U.S. District Judge Sharon Gleason dismissed the case in a 20-page order, finding the department lacked standing and offered "no workable plan" to separate and investigate disputed ballots while keeping them secret. The department appealed the same day.

Outcome: Stopped.

What stopped it (or didn't): A federal judge, before Election Day. The appeal is pending in the Ninth Circuit, and certification has not happened.

Sources: CBS News, Nov. 1 · Votebeat, Oct. 29 · Just Security litigation tracker

9. An alleged decoy candidate in Alaska

Who and how: The New York Times reported on Oct. 28 that Democratic operatives tied to Mary Peltola's campaign helped recruit and support Daniel J. Sullivan to draw votes from the senator. Peltola has said she is "not interested in tricking voters," and the Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee denies involvement. Daniel J. Sullivan denies running at Democrats' request.

What happened: He appears as Daniel J. Sullivan Jr., with no party label. Gov. Mike Dunleavy ordered a state investigation, and federal prosecutors opened a criminal one. He received about 3,500 votes, about 1.6%, as of Nov. 4. A ranked-choice researcher put the chance of his acting as a spoiler at "less than a 1%" if Republicans ranked their choices.

Outcome: Still open.

What stopped it (or didn't): Publicity, a ballot that lists party affiliation for the incumbent, and ranked-choice voting limited any effect. Whether anyone broke a law is unresolved.

Sources: Votebeat, Oct. 29 · Votebeat, Nov. 2 · Votebeat, Nov. 4 · AP via KPTV, Nov. 3

10. Criminal process aimed at the Alaska race during the vote

Who and how: The federal criminal inquiry into the second Sullivan, run from the U.S. Attorney's Office in Alaska, issued more than 100 subpoenas, sent FBI agents to the homes of his donors the weekend before the election, and on Election Day sent target letters to Marc Elias, a lawyer for Democratic campaigns, and others. The president had written that Peltola "should suffer the Legal and Political consequences." On Nov. 5, Axios reported, as summarized by Just Security, that the president posted that votes for the second Sullivan should go to the incumbent.

What happened: No one has been charged. AP notes that recruiting spoiler candidates has been common for decades without criminal scrutiny.

Outcome: Still open.

What stopped it (or didn't): Nothing yet. The count is in state hands, and a grand jury has not acted.

Sources: AP via KPTV, Nov. 3 · Votebeat, Oct. 29 · Just Security, Early Edition, Nov. 6

11. Prosecuting noncitizen registration and voting case by case

Who and how: On Oct. 19 the Justice Department charged 28 lawful permanent residents in California with registration and voting crimes, many also with false statements on naturalization applications. All 28 were on the 20,000-name list. The department said it had charged 113 noncitizens in 20 states in seven weeks.

What happened: NPR reported that a number of those charged do not appear to have voted, and some registered more than 20 years ago. McCotter said the department "will not look the other way while noncitizens vote."

Outcome: Still open.

What stopped it (or didn't): Nothing needed to. A charge against a named person, who gets a lawyer, a judge and a jury, is the lawful way to enforce the citizenship rule. The cases are pending.

Sources: NPR via OPB, Oct. 20

The tally. Of these 11 efforts, six were stopped, one partly succeeded, none fully succeeded, and four are still open. Every attempt to set aside ballots or delay certification failed, most of them in court. What worked for its authors, at least in part, was pressure rather than results: investigations that ran for weeks before a judge paused them, and prosecution warnings and subpoenas that reached election officials whether or not anyone is charged. One of the open items is alleged conduct by the other side. A tally cannot capture what did not happen because of these efforts, such as eligible citizens who stayed home. We have no measure of that.

Part 3. What held, and where it bent

County and state election officials. The first check was the officials who run elections. Los Angeles County's registrar did not treat the federal thumb drive as secure and said removals must rest on "verifiable information, not assertions of unconfirmed data matching." County staff tested the federal list and found citizens on it. Washington's secretary of state refused to set ballots aside without individualized proof. Napa's registrar kept counting. A federal demand had to persuade thousands of local officials bound by state law, and no court ordered any of them to comply.

Courts, at every level. District judges in Los Angeles, San Francisco, Oakland, Anchorage and Washington, D.C., ruled quickly, often within a day or two, and most of the rulings rested on state authority over elections or on the unreliability of the federal lists. The Supreme Court turned away the one election application it received, with no noted dissent and without asking California to respond. The Ninth Circuit was less uniform: panels split 2–1 more than once, and in the election workers' case the full court reversed course within about a day, ending, by the tracker's account, on the government's side. Protection depended on which judges sat.

Voters, through referendums. Missouri's referendum overturned a map drawn mid-decade, and Amendment 6 protects future referendum results from legislative override. Arizona voters declined to write mail-voting rules into the constitution. In each case voters used a procedure the state constitution gives them. The mechanism would have worked the same way had the votes gone the other way.

The press. Reporting on the federal list, including Los Angeles County's sampling of it, gave courts and the public a way to test the government's claims before ballots were counted.

Where the checks were thin or slow. Congress played no visible part in the fall's disputes. The Election Assistance Commission has had no commissioners since July, and the Federal Election Commission has lacked a quorum since April 2025. Some court relief came through the government's own assurances; Judge Walton denied the NAACP's request on the strength of promises about who the monitors would be. Not every challenger could get relief: Chief Judge Boasberg denied the Democratic Senate committee's request for lack of standing. The Ninth Circuit's holding on Section 11(b), if it stands, removes a route private groups have used to protect voters and election workers from intimidation. And the courts could only act after the letters, subpoenas and agent visits had already landed on the people running the election.

Sources: AP via WDIV, Oct. 14 · Just Security litigation tracker · St. Louis Public Radio, Nov. 3 · Votebeat, Nov. 4 · Washington Post via DNYUZ, Oct. 17

Part 4. What this election means for the health of American democracy

Electoral Integrity. Outlook: Mixed. The machinery worked under strain: paper ballots, emergency bins, local canvasses and state law carried the count, and courts at every level said the executive branch may not decide which ballots a state counts. Those are real gains for state control of elections. Against them, the federal tools used this fall remain available, the commission that supports election administrators has no members, and one appeals ruling may have narrowed the legal protection for people who count ballots. Certification, the next test, has not happened anywhere.

Civil Liberties. Outlook: Unchanged. The orders protecting voters' data and pausing investigations of suspected noncitizens are temporary, and the pause on field investigations expired when polls closed. Nothing in the election itself added or removed a lasting protection.

Rule of Law. Outlook: Mixed. Every election ruling we tracked appears to have been obeyed, and the government took its disagreements to higher courts rather than acting around them. At the same time, federal prosecutors used criminal process during the vote against election officials and against a lawyer who represents one party in election disputes, and a ranking official signed prosecution warnings that named no violation. Whether those tools are tested before grand juries, or simply left hanging, will decide which way this goes.

Checks & Balances. Outlook: Stronger. When the new Congress convenes in January, the party that does not hold the presidency will control both chambers, according to AP projections. That gives Congress its standard means of checking the executive: committee subpoenas, oversight hearings, control over appropriations and the Senate's power to reject nominees. The powers are the same whichever party holds them; the incentive to use them changes. In the election itself, the federal structure held: a court grounded its ruling in the Elections Clause and the Supreme Court declined to disturb a state's count.

Political Pluralism. Outlook: Mixed. The basic test of pluralism is whether the party in power can lose, and it did, broadly and without a fight over the result. But the government's criminal process reached an opposition lawyer on Election Day and opposition donors at their homes, and earlier this fall it reached an opposition member of Congress during her campaign. Party competition proved strong; the cost of working for the opposition went up.

Transparency & Anti-Corruption. Outlook: Unchanged. Courts forced some disclosure in litigation, such as the federal list, but the election did not change the bodies that police money and conduct in politics. The Federal Election Commission still cannot act. Oversight power arrives in January, not now.

Democratic Culture. Outlook: Stronger. The person whose acceptance was most in doubt accepted the results on election night, and the losing candidates we could check conceded, some before races were called. The limit is that this was the easy case. Mitchell's own line, that no one looks under the hood when results are not close, describes acceptance that depends on the margin, and the Alaska post shows the habit of disputing a close count has not gone away.

Overall assessment. This election tested whether the federal executive could reach into the state machinery of voting and counting, and the machinery held. It held because it is spread across thousands of local offices bound by state law, because judges at every level read the Constitution to leave the count with the states, and because officials refused demands that had no court order behind them. The president's quick acceptance closed off the most feared scenario, a dispute over the national result. By the accounts we found, the election was administered about as well as recent ones, under far heavier federal pressure.

The election did not repair what made it a test. The executive branch used civil suits, emergency applications, letters with prosecution warnings, grand jury subpoenas, agent visits and target letters, and none of those powers has been limited by anything that happened this week except a few temporary orders. Some legal protections may have narrowed. The national bodies that support and police elections are inactive. Pam Smith of Verified Voting called the calm "a pause, not a resolution." The real strength of the system is still untested in a close national election in which the losing side controls federal law enforcement.

The change in control of Congress matters for institutions, not for any party. Beginning in January, an opposition majority will hold subpoena power, appropriations and confirmation votes. That restores a check that was largely idle this fall. It also means the next two years will test whether the executive complies with congressional subpoenas.

Counter-read: The case against this assessment runs both ways. From one side: we credit "the system" for holding when the margins did the work. The government did not lose the legal argument about intimidating election workers; on the record we could find, it won it on Election Day. A federal criminal inquiry is still running against the other party's lawyer, and the unmeasured cost, eligible naturalized citizens who stayed home, may be larger than any ballot the courts saved. On that view, Mixed and Stronger are too generous. From the other side: almost everything in Part 2 was lawful process. The government sued, filed applications, sent letters about real statutes, and lost, which is how the design is supposed to work. The department charged individual violators the lawful way, and the Alaska inquiry concerns a scheme that a newspaper reported and a Republican governor also chose to investigate. On that view, calling this "pressure" overstates it. The test for our assessment is concrete: if the Alaska count is certified on schedule by state officials, the target letters produce no charges, and the investigations of suspected noncitizen voters do not resume during the canvass, the reassuring reading gains ground. If any of those goes the other way, the cautious reading was right.

From the archive

Federal election supervision came from Congress. In 1871, the second of the Enforcement Acts permitted federal oversight of local and state elections if any two citizens in a town of more than 20,000 people asked for it. In 1890, the Lodge Bill, which its critics called the Force Bill, would have let federal circuit courts appoint supervisors for U.S. House elections on a petition of 500 citizens, with power to inspect registration lists, challenge voters and certify the count, backed by deputy marshals. It passed the House by six votes and died to a filibuster in the Senate. Federal power over elections in that era came from statutes, applied through courts and in response to citizen petitions. This fall's disputes turned on whether the executive could act on its own, and the courts that ruled said it could not.

Sources: Wikipedia, Enforcement Acts · Wikipedia, Lodge Bill

A claim of noncitizen voting, tested after the count. After Loretta Sanchez defeated Rep. Robert Dornan in 1996 by 984 votes, 979 after a recount, Dornan contested the result in the House. On May 14, 1997, the House oversight committee subpoenaed the Immigration and Naturalization Service to match its records against Orange County's voter registrations. A task force found 624 people who had registered illegally and 124 improper absentee ballots, 748 invalid votes in all. In a report dated Feb. 11, 1998, the committee recommended dismissing the contest because that number was "substantially less than the 979 vote margin." The ballots were counted first; the claim was tested afterward, case by case, by the body the Constitution makes judge of House elections.

Sources: H. Rept. 105-416, Feb. 1998

What to watch

  • Nov. 9: The Senate returns. Current funding runs through Dec. 11.
  • About Nov. 13: The last day for some Alaska absentee ballots, 10 days after the election (our arithmetic).
  • Nov. 16: Judge Thompson's order in SEIU v. DOJ was set to expire, though it appears to be stayed.
  • Nov. 18: Alaska begins ranked-choice tabulation, if needed.
  • About Nov. 19: The Washington order barring prosecution threats over ballot counting, reported Nov. 5 as lasting two weeks, would expire.
  • Pending, no date: state canvasses and certifications; the Ninth Circuit appeal in the Alaska certification case (No. 26-7304); any charges from the Alaska grand jury; whether Homeland Security resumes field investigations; the D.C. Circuit appeal of the voter-roll ruling (No. 26-5362); Westchester County's investigation; final counts on Alaska's ranked-choice repeal and Arizona's Prop. 144.
  • January 2027: The new Congress convenes. Gilchrist takes office in Michigan on Jan. 1.

What we could not verify

Our research for this edition was narrower than we wanted, so several questions remain open. We did not find a national turnout estimate, including from the University of Florida Election Lab. We did not find a post-election measure of voter confidence in the count; the AP Voter Poll, which we opened, does not report one. We could not verify results of secretary of state races beyond Arizona and Michigan, including Nevada, Georgia and Wisconsin, or how candidates labeled election deniers fared overall. We did not find state certification calendars, and we found no report of a county refusing or threatening to refuse certification. Our account of the Ninth Circuit's Nov. 3 en banc order comes only from the Just Security litigation tracker; we could not open the order, and earlier reports said Judge Thompson's order stood. The Washington order of Nov. 5, the president's Nov. 5 post about Alaska votes, the Mississippi Republican statement and the finding on foreign interference come from Just Security's summaries of Politico, Axios, The Hill and The New York Times, which we could not open; we could not confirm that the Washington order came in OneAmerica Votes v. Trump. We did not confirm whether the Los Angeles officials appeared before the grand jury on Nov. 4. We could not confirm the 1894 repeal of the federal election supervision laws against a source we opened, so we left it out. Counts continue in several states, and all results here are unofficial. Corrections run at the top of the next issue.

Our full source list and standards are on the sources page.

Past briefings