Weekly Briefing No.
6
·
Week of October 24 – 30, 2026

Courts refuse to set California's ballots aside. Prosecutors put every state on notice.

Retrospective edition compiled Nov. 7 from reporting dated Oct. 24–30. In the last full week before the election, a district judge and two appeals panels refused the Justice Department's bid to make California hold back about 20,000 ballots, and a judge barred threats against election workers, while the department warned election officials in all 50 states of prosecution and planned about 1,000 poll monitors. A grand jury declined to indict Cassidy Hutchinson, and prosecutors charged James Comey a third time by information, without a grand jury.

Published
October 30, 2026
Edited by Dabney Standley
Electoral Integrity
mixed
Federal officials pressed states to sideline ballots and warned election officials nationwide of prosecution, while courts refused the ballot demands and ordered the threats to stop.
Civil Liberties
hold
An appeals court left in place an order pausing DHS voter investigations in nine states that judges found had deterred citizens.
Rule of Law
down
Prosecutors charged a president's critic without a grand jury to beat a limitations deadline on conduct earlier prosecutors had declined to charge.
Checks & Balances
hold
Congress is out until Nov. 9; courts settled the week's federal-state disputes over election power.
Political Pluralism
hold
A grand jury refused to indict a former White House aide over her testimony against the president.
Transparency & Anti-Corruption
hold
Courts ordered the Justice Department to name the states it warned and share its disputed list, while monitor sites stay undisclosed until Election Day.
Democratic Culture
hold
No qualifying institutional event; election officials described fear in sworn filings.

The week in brief

The last full week before the Nov. 3 election was fought over ballots already cast. The Justice Department asked courts to make California hold back ballots from about 20,000 voters it suspects are noncitizens. A district judge and two appeals panels refused, partly because counties had no way to pull those ballots out once processing began. The department asked Washington state to set aside up to 400 more, and Secretary of State Steve Hobbs said no after finding citizens on the list. On Oct. 29, the department's second-ranking official sent letters to election officials across the country reminding them that losing election records can bring a year in prison. A federal judge in San Francisco then barred the department from threatening election workers with prosecution. Outside elections, a Washington grand jury declined to indict Cassidy Hutchinson, and prosecutors brought a third criminal case against James Comey by a route that skipped the grand jury.

The week's events

  • Oct 26 · Appeals court dismisses DOJ's first California ballot appeal · Electoral Integrity · Checks & Balances
  • Oct 26 · DOJ asks Washington to set aside up to 400 ballots; Hobbs refuses · Electoral Integrity
  • Oct 26 · Third Comey case, filed without a grand jury, unsealed · Rule of Law · Political Pluralism
  • Oct 27 · Grand jury declines to indict Cassidy Hutchinson · Political Pluralism · Rule of Law
  • Oct 27 · DOJ to send about 1,000 election monitors to all 50 states · Electoral Integrity · Transparency & Anti-Corruption
  • Oct 28 · Judge Carter denies DOJ bid to set aside 20,000 California ballots · Electoral Integrity · Checks & Balances
  • Oct 29 · DOJ letters warn election officials in all 50 states of prosecution · Electoral Integrity · Rule of Law
  • Oct 29 · Boasberg orders DOJ to name states that got ballot letters · Transparency & Anti-Corruption · Electoral Integrity
  • Oct 30 · Appeals court again refuses California ballot demand, 2–1 · Electoral Integrity
  • Oct 30 · Judge Thompson bars DOJ and DHS threats against election workers · Electoral Integrity · Rule of Law
  • Oct 30 · Appeals court keeps DHS voter investigations paused in nine states · Civil Liberties · Electoral Integrity
  • Oct 30 · Court orders DOJ to share 20,000-name list with challengers · Transparency & Anti-Corruption

The full edition

The complete edition, as sent to subscribers. Get it in your inbox every Friday. How the signals work: Methodology.

Retrospective edition. This issue was compiled on Nov. 7, 2026, after a four-week gap in publication, from reporting dated Oct. 24–30. We kept the readings and the "Watch next week" list to what was known by Oct. 30.

Electoral Integrity

Courts refuse to make California set aside 20,000 ballots

Instrument: United States v. California (C.D. Cal., Judge David O. Carter); two orders of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 9th Circuit · Status: request denied at both levels; the Justice Department has said it will go to the Supreme Court · Date: Oct. 26, Oct. 28 and Oct. 30

On Oct. 13 the Justice Department gave Los Angeles County a list of about 20,000 people it called potential noncitizens on state rolls and demanded California set aside their ballots. It sued on Oct. 15. Los Angeles County found 7,035 names with county addresses; in a sample of 200, about a quarter said they were born in the United States. On Oct. 26 a 9th Circuit panel dismissed the department's first appeal 2–1 for lack of jurisdiction. On Oct. 28 Judge Carter denied a temporary restraining order in a 26-page opinion. He wrote that the order would "wreak havoc" on the election, reasoned that segregating ballots would work like a purge inside the 90-day window before a federal election, and added that "California and its people are sovereign, too." By then more than 3.7 million Californians had voted. On Oct. 30 a second 9th Circuit panel denied relief 2–1. Judges Mark Bennett and Gabriel Sanchez wrote that "there is no feasible way to identify and segregate the ballots of specific individuals." Judge Patrick Bumatay dissented. The same week, federal prosecutors served grand jury subpoenas on Los Angeles County election officials, at least three of whom were asked to appear the day after the election.

Our reading: Electoral Integrity strengthening on this event. A trial judge and an appeals panel held that a list of contested accuracy could not justify pulling ballots out of a count already under way, and the courts kept the conduct of the election with the state that runs it.

Counter-read: Noncitizens may not vote in federal elections, and Judge Bumatay's dissent argues the federal government may step in when a state will not check. If even a few hundred names on the list are ineligible, the refusal means those ballots are counted with no way to retrieve them. The rulings turned on timing and feasibility as much as on the merits.

Sources: Votebeat, Oct. 26 · ABC30, Oct. 28 · AP via KSAT, Oct. 30 · AP via News4Jax, Oct. 30 · Just Security litigation tracker

Justice Department warns election officials in all 50 states

Instrument: letters signed by Acting Deputy Attorney General Trent McCotter, dated Oct. 29; a separate Justice Department letter to Washington state, Oct. 26 · Status: sent; Washington refused the ballot request · Date: Oct. 26 and Oct. 29

On Oct. 26 the department told Washington officials to separate as many as 400 ballots it said could be cast by noncitizens, with a deadline of Wednesday afternoon. Secretary of State Steve Hobbs refused after an initial check found U.S. citizens on the list. "Without individualized proof of ineligibility, it would be both irresponsible and illegal," he wrote. Three days later, McCotter signed identical letters that officials told Votebeat went to all 50 states. They remind election officials that federal law requires them to keep ballots and registration records for 22 months, and that willful failure is "punishable by up to a year in prison and a $1,000 fine." The letters cite no violation or pending investigation. Some went to the wrong inboxes, and Texas's was addressed to a secretary of state who left office in July. Joshua Douglas, an election law professor at the University of Kentucky, said he had never seen such a nationwide letter before an election. The department did not answer Votebeat's questions about the timing.

Our reading: Electoral Integrity eroding on this event. The duty to keep records is old and real. Sending a prosecution warning to every state's election officials days before the vote, with no violation named and while the same official was pressing California to hold back ballots, raises the personal risk of running an election for people the department has not accused of anything.

Counter-read: The letters state the law accurately and impose no new duty. The 22-month rule matters most right after an election, which is when a reminder is most useful, and no election official was charged or ordered to do anything new. Connecticut's secretary of state said her office complies as a matter of course.

From the archive: President Eisenhower signed the Civil Rights Act of 1960 on May 6, 1960. Its Title III required every officer of election to keep voting records for 22 months and hand them over on the attorney general's written demand. Historian William Sturkey writes that over the next 16 months Attorneys General William Rogers and Robert Kennedy demanded records from 26 Southern counties where Black residents had alleged discrimination. The records showed white applicants excused from literacy tests that Black applicants had to take, and the department filed 19 voter discrimination cases by the end of 1962. The statute was built for targeted demands where evidence of wrongdoing existed. This week's letters invoke the same law across all 50 states without naming a wrong.

Sources: Votebeat, Oct. 30 · Votebeat, Oct. 29 · KPTV, Oct. 29 · Archive: AAIHS (William Sturkey), Feb. 8, 2018 · Wikipedia, Civil Rights Act of 1960

Judge bars the Justice Department from threatening election workers

Instrument: temporary restraining order, SEIU v. U.S. Department of Justice (N.D. Cal., Judge Trina L. Thompson) · Status: in effect until Nov. 16 · Date: Oct. 30

A union representing California election workers and its allies sued on Oct. 29. One declaration came from Santa Clara County registrar Matt Moreles, who described "a severe chilling effect on my staff and me." A day later Judge Thompson ordered the Justice Department and DHS not to "threaten, intimidate or coerce" state or local election officials or workers. The order bars them from threatening prosecution over the department's ballot directives, from demanding that officials stop processing or counting ballots of voters the government calls ineligible, and from demanding the removal of specific voters from the rolls. She found the plaintiffs likely to succeed and called the threats "contrary to law" and "arbitrary and capricious." "Given the consequences of inaction, the Court sees no reason to delay its ruling," she wrote. The department had not weighed in before she ruled.

Our reading: Electoral Integrity strengthening on this event. The order protects the people who count ballots from being made personally liable for following state law while a federal dispute about that law is still in court.

Counter-read: The order came before the government responded and reaches nationwide, both reasons for an appeals court to narrow it. Federal prosecutors have a lawful role in election crimes, and an order against "threats" can be read to chill legitimate warnings about the law.

Sources: Reuters via EWN, Oct. 31 · AP via KSAT, Oct. 30 · Votebeat, Nov. 2 · Just Security litigation tracker

About 1,000 federal monitors will watch the election in all 50 states

Instrument: Justice Department election monitoring program · Status: announced; full list of locations withheld until Election Day · Date: reported Oct. 27

Justice Department spokesperson Kiersten Pels told States Newsroom that about 1,000 monitors will go to all 50 states. "Every monitor will merely observe and report any potential violations of federal law," she said. In the 2022 midterms the department sent monitors to 64 jurisdictions in 24 states. Some locations are known: King County, Washington; Multnomah County, Oregon; Salt Lake County, Utah; and Portland and Lewiston, Maine. Utah Lt. Gov. Deidre Henderson, a Republican, said the department assured her monitors "won't be approaching voters." Maine Secretary of State Shenna Bellows, a Democrat, said her office "will monitor the monitors very carefully." The NAACP has sued for records about the program; Judge Sparkle Sooknanan denied its request for an emergency order to produce them, and the suit continues.

Our reading: Electoral Integrity holding on this event. Federal observation of elections is lawful and long-standing, and the department says its monitors will observe and report. The scale is new; what monitors do on Election Day is the test.

Counter-read: A program many times larger than the last midterm's, run by a department that is suing states over their rolls and warning their officials of prosecution, may change how voters and poll workers behave whatever the monitors do. Withholding the list until Election Day leaves officials little time to prepare.

Sources: States Newsroom via Valley News Live, Oct. 27

Civil Liberties

Appeals court keeps DHS voter investigations paused in nine states

Instrument: per curiam order, California Nurses Association v. Mullin, No. 26-7139 (9th Cir.); the full court denied rehearing en banc the same day · Status: the district court's pause stands until polls close Nov. 3 · Date: Oct. 30

On Oct. 21, U.S. District Judge Araceli Martinez-Olguin ordered DHS to halt its investigations of suspected noncitizen voters in California, Connecticut, Georgia, Missouri, Nevada, New York, Pennsylvania, Washington and Wisconsin until the polls close. She called the government's lists "voluminous and unreliable" and noted that agents were limited to 12 minutes per person during the surge phase. She rested the order on harm to unions' and voter groups' work helping citizens vote, not on a finding that anyone's right to vote was infringed. On Oct. 30 a 9th Circuit panel rejected the government's request to pause her order, finding that the investigations had led some citizens to avoid election-related activity for fear of being wrongly targeted. DHS has said it has "no plans to question or investigate" people it believes are citizens.

Our reading: Civil Liberties holding. An existing order survived appeal. Citizens who help others register and vote keep working through Election Day without federal agents visiting their homes over a list a judge found unreliable.

Counter-read: The order is short and narrow by design: it lifts when the polls close, and it does not find the investigations unlawful. Enforcing the law against noncitizen voting is a legitimate federal task, and a pause tied to the calendar may simply move the investigations to the weeks when results are being certified.

Sources: AP via ClickOrlando, Oct. 22 · AP via KSAT, Oct. 30 · Just Security litigation tracker

Rule of Law

Prosecutors bring a third case against James Comey, without a grand jury

Instrument: criminal information filed in federal district court in Washington, D.C., unsealed Oct. 26; motion to dismiss heard by U.S. District Judge Trevor McFadden · Status: pending; the judge postponed ruling while prosecutors seek an indictment · Date: Oct. 26 and Oct. 30

On Oct. 5, the day the 10-year limitations period ran out, prosecutors filed a two-count criminal information accusing the former FBI director of disclosing sensitive information and conspiring to do so in October 2016. They allege he had FBI staff speak with a New York Times reporter about a story on email surveillance. An information is a charge filed by prosecutors alone; Comey did not waive his right to a grand jury. His lawyers say two U.S. attorneys investigated the same episode and declined to prosecute, and that the charge is time-barred because no grand jury acted by the deadline. At an Oct. 30 hearing, prosecutor Dustin Farahnak said a grand jury is hearing evidence now. Judge McFadden put off ruling, said he would be "extremely frustrated" by any "dawn raid" to arrest Comey, and observed that "ham sandwiches are harder to indict these days." This is the third criminal case against Comey; a court dismissed the first, and he has moved to dismiss the second as vindictive.

Our reading: Rule of Law eroding on this event. A charge the department could not, or did not, take to a grand jury before the deadline was filed anyway to hold the date, against a prominent critic of the president, over conduct earlier prosecutors examined and passed on. The grand jury's role is to stand between the government and the accused, and this filing was built to work around it.

Counter-read: Filing an information to preserve a charge is a known tactic, and the court has not ruled on whether it works. The judge is supervising closely and has not let the case advance. If the evidence reaches into 2017, as the prosecutor suggested, a timely indictment is possible, and a grand jury in Washington may refuse it.

Sources: NPR via WYPR, Oct. 26 · AP via KSAT, Oct. 30 · Voz, Oct. 26

Checks & Balances

No primary event this week. Congress is in recess until Nov. 9, and funding runs through Dec. 11. The week's contests over federal and state power were settled in court. Judge Carter's California opinion turned on the Elections Clause and the states' authority over how elections are run. At the Oct. 25 appellate hearing, Judge Bennett told the department's lawyer that under the Elections Clause the state legislature has "the right to determine the manner of the elections." (Votebeat, Oct. 26)

Political Pluralism

Grand jury refuses to indict Cassidy Hutchinson

Instrument: federal grand jury in Washington, D.C.; returned no true bill · Status: no charge; reported by AP and The New York Times citing people familiar with the matter · Date: Oct. 27

A grand jury declined the Justice Department's request to indict Cassidy Hutchinson, the former aide to White House Chief of Staff Mark Meadows whose June 2022 testimony to the House Jan. 6 committee described the president's conduct on that day. AP's two sources did not describe the charges sought. The Times reported that the Civil Rights Division, led by Harmeet Dhillon, ran the case, an unusual assignment, and that some department prosecutors doubted a conviction could be won. Part of Hutchinson's account, a secondhand story about the president grabbing at the steering wheel of his SUV, was later contradicted by a Secret Service driver. Hutchinson declined to comment through her lawyer. The Times noted that a Washington grand jury in February also refused to indict six Democratic lawmakers.

Our reading: Political Pluralism holding. Three weeks ago we scored the investigation as eroding because it raised the cost of testifying against a president. This week a body of citizens weighed the government's evidence and declined to charge. The cost was imposed; the check held.

Counter-read: One could call this strengthening, since a grand jury rebuke is rare and public. One could also say it changes nothing: a no-bill does not bar prosecutors from trying again, and the months of investigation already sent the message to future witnesses.

From the archive: In 2010, the most recent year with data when FiveThirtyEight examined the question in 2014, U.S. attorneys prosecuted about 162,000 federal cases, and grand juries declined to indict in 11 of them, according to the Bureau of Justice Statistics. A grand jury refusal is ordinarily close to unheard of. Washington grand juries have now refused politically charged cases more than once this year, which tells prosecutors something about how their evidence is landing with ordinary citizens.

Sources: AP via Click2Houston, Oct. 27 · New York Times via Honolulu Star-Advertiser, Oct. 27 · Archive: FiveThirtyEight (archived Dec. 2014)

Transparency & Anti-Corruption

Courts order the Justice Department to show who got its ballot letters, and share its list

Instrument: expedited discovery order, DSCC v. Trump, No. 1:26-cv-03674 (D.D.C., Chief Judge James Boasberg); order in a separate suit over use of federal immigration data · Status: disclosure due Oct. 30 in the first; the government appealed the second the same evening · Date: Oct. 29 and Oct. 30

Democratic Party committees and congressional leaders sued on Oct. 20 to stop federal demands that states remove voters or hold back ballots. On Oct. 29, Chief Judge Boasberg granted expedited discovery in part and ordered the department to list every state whose officials received its letters about noncitizen voting, by Friday. He said he would rule on the request to block the conduct by Nov. 2. "The harder question for me is your standing to do it," he told the plaintiffs. A department lawyer, Christian Dibblee, said a letter "just notifies them of a potential violation of federal law." On Oct. 30, in a suit brought by the Coalition for Humane Immigrant Rights and the UCLA Voting Rights Project, a federal court ordered the department to give the plaintiffs' lawyers the list of some 20,000 names it used in California, so they can test who is on it.

Our reading: Transparency & Anti-Corruption holding. The government had been pressing states with letters and a list that the public could not see. Ordinary discovery forced both into the open, at least for the parties, which is how courts are supposed to test claims of this kind.

Counter-read: Disclosure to litigants is not disclosure to the public, the list order is on appeal, and the department still will not say where its 1,000 monitors will be until Election Day. On the other side, the list holds personal data of people who may be citizens, and sharing it widely carries its own risk.

Sources: Goodreturns, Oct. 30 · Votebeat, Oct. 30 · AP via News4Jax, Oct. 30 · Just Security litigation tracker

Democratic Culture

No institutional event this week met our bar. Two things are worth recording. In sworn declarations filed in the election workers' suit, David Becker of the Center for Election Innovation & Research said officials report being "scared and exhausted by the onslaught of threats." And after The New York Times reported on Oct. 28 that Democratic operatives tied to Mary Peltola's Senate campaign helped recruit a second Dan Sullivan onto Alaska's ballot, Gov. Mike Dunleavy ordered an investigation, and the president wrote that Peltola "should suffer the Legal and Political consequences." We do not score remarks. We note this one because a president calling for legal consequences against a named opponent days before a vote, while his Justice Department is already suing over the same race, blurs the line between a political attack and a law enforcement signal, whichever party is on the receiving end. (Votebeat, Oct. 29 · Votebeat, Nov. 2)

Data point of the week. None. We did not find a credible national survey or index released this week that met our standard. The most recent we saw, an ABC News/Washington Post/Ipsos poll released Oct. 20, falls in an earlier week.

Watch next week

  • Nov. 2: Chief Judge Boasberg's promised ruling on emergency relief in DSCC v. Trump.
  • Nov. 3: Election Day. The Justice Department says it will release its list of monitored locations. The pause on DHS voter investigations in nine states lifts when polls close.
  • Nov. 4: At least three Los Angeles County election officials have been asked to appear before a federal grand jury.
  • Pending, no date: the department's promised Supreme Court application in the California ballot case; its appeal of the order sharing the 20,000-name list; the Justice Department's Alaska suit seeking to block certification of the Senate race in some circumstances, which Alaska has asked the court to dismiss; a grand jury's decision on an indictment of James Comey and Judge McFadden's ruling on the motion to dismiss; the 9th Circuit's decision on a stay in Rogoff v. Trump; the D.C. Circuit appeal of the White House press injunction.
  • Nov. 9: The Senate returns. Judge Thompson's order runs through Nov. 16. Current funding runs through Dec. 11.

What we could not verify

We could not open NPR's or the Baltimore Sun's reports on the California rulings, or the Times story on Alaska; we relied on Votebeat, AP, ABC30 and Reuters versions. We could not confirm the specific statute charged against Comey, or which judge issued the Oct. 30 order to share the 20,000-name list; a litigation tracker lists a Chief Judge Boasberg order in Trujillo v. DHS, and we could not confirm that it is the coalition's suit AP describes. Reports differ on whether Judge Thompson's order issued Friday or over the weekend; we use the docket date of Oct. 30. We could not confirm the date of the president's post about Peltola. We found no new procedural step this week in the Sooknanan voter-roll case, the Georgia board dispute, the Texas registration backlog, the ICE fines case, the Boasberg contempt appeal, the DHS jets, or the Missouri ActBlue demand. Corrections run at the top of the next issue.

Our full source list and standards are on the sources page.

Past briefings